Executive Summary

The Forsyth-Warren Tavern Museum seeks rezoning approval to secure its long-term future as a cultural and educational institution. Under current zoning, the museum is limited to temporary permits of twelve months or less, leaving its operations without permanence or stability. Despite the Tavern’s listing on the National Register of Historic Places, its buildings are considered non-conforming under existing regulations. This designation prohibits the reconstruction of historically documented additions and outbuildings that once defined the site’s character.

​For several years, the museum has faced resistance from the Town of Cambria, resulting in a multi-year campaign to preserve the Tavern against regulatory and political obstacles. This campaign has culminated in a broad petition for rezoning, supported by residents, educators, and preservation advocates. Rezoning is essential to safeguard the Tavern’s heritage, enable responsible restoration, and ensure its role as a community anchor for generations to come.

Historic Significance

The Forsyth-Warren Tavern is one of Niagara County’s oldest surviving landmarks. Built in the early 19th century, it served as a vital stop for travelers and a gathering place for local residents. Its architecture and history embody the rural heritage of Cambria and the surrounding region. The Tavern is not merely a building — it is a living classroom, a tangible link to the county’s formative years, and a rare surviving example of early rural hospitality and civic life.

Current Zoning Challenges

These constraints jeopardize the museum’s ability to fulfill its mission and deny the community the full benefit of its heritage resources.

  • Temporary Permits: The museum is restricted to permits of twelve months or less, undermining stability and long-term planning.
  • Non-Conforming Status: Despite National Register recognition, the Tavern’s buildings are classified as non-conforming, limiting restoration and adaptive reuse.
  • Prohibition on Reconstruction: Current zoning prohibits rebuilding the site’s lost additions and outbuildings, preventing historically accurate restoration.
  • Town Opposition: The Town of Cambria has historically opposed the museum’s efforts, forcing a prolonged campaign to secure its survival.

Community Benefits of RezoninG

Rezoning would transform the museum’s position from precarious to permanent, unlocking opportunities for:
  • Education: Expanded school programs, interpretive tours, and curriculum integration.
  • Economy: Increased tourism, local business support, and eligibility for preservation grants.
  • Community Life: A stable gathering space for lectures, cultural programming, and intergenerational engagement.
  • Preservation: Restoration of lost additions and buildings, ensuring architectural integrity and historical accuracy.

Alignment with Policy Goals

Rezoning aligns with Cambria’s Comprehensive Plan by:
  • Preserving rural character and historic resources.
  • Promoting heritage tourism and cultural programming.
  • Supporting low-intensity, community-oriented land use.
  • Enhancing educational and civic opportunities.

The Campaign to Save the Tavern

For years, the museum has fought to overcome regulatory barriers and opposition. Through public hearings, outreach, and grassroots advocacy, supporters have rallied to protect the Tavern. This effort has culminated in a major petition for rezoning, representing broad community support and a shared vision for Cambria’s heritage.

Request for Agency Review

We invite your agency to:
  • Review the rezoning and development plans.
  • Provide feedback on preservation, museum operations, and community impact.
  • Consider issuing a letter of support to strengthen the rezoning application.
Your expertise and endorsement will help ensure the Forsyth-Warren Tavern Museum’s survival and success as a cornerstone of rural heritage education.

What's the Plan for Forsyth's